This short paper offers a brief summary of four different views concerning the reconciliation of divine omniscience and human freedom such as. Four views provides a venue for wellknown proponents of four. Scotus merged it with a legal distinction between a rightful act according to the. So divine foreknowledge entails that all future events are necessary, and that we do not have free will at least under a certain understanding of free will this is a form of argument known as conditional proof.
This is especially clear in those cases where gods eternal purpose of redemption through christ is represented as a mystery which is known by god and which can be known by man only when it pleases god to reveal it ephesians 1. What a perfect way to explore the question of gods omniscience. This is especially clear in those cases where gods eternal purpose of redemption through christ is represented as a mystery which is known by god and which can be known by man only when it pleases god to reveal it. Boyd, god limits his control, four views on divine providence, 197. Omniscience brills studies in intellectual history craig, professor of philosophy william lane on. The idea that divine foreknowledge is incompatible with free will rests on the assumption premise 8 of the above argument that if one cannot do otherwise, one does not act. Boyd of bethel college presents the opentheism view, david hunt of whittier college weighs in on the simple foreknowledge view, william lane craig of talbot school of theology takes the. Predestination, divine foreknowledge, and free will.
Omniscience and divine foreknowledge internet encyclopedia. Boyd of bethel college presents the opentheism view, david hunt of whittier college weighs in on the simpleforeknowledge view, william lane craig of talbot school of theology takes the. Open theism, molinism, simple foreknowledge, and augustiniancalvinistic. Boyd, david hunt, william lane craig, and paul helm. Q12 hold the same views as armenian for general providence and incompatibilist freedom q3foreknowing an incompatibilist free choice is impossibleare against armenians q4 does god foreknow no. If god knows everything we will do before we do it, can our actions be free. Four views provides a venue for wellknown proponents of four distinct views of divine foreknowledge to present their cases. Seattle pacific university 12 3015 divine foreknowledge and human free will. The bible, which is gods revelation of himself, undeniably and frequently affirms, argues, and illustrates the case that god possesses this amazing trait. This book on divine foreknowledge cuts rightinto the heart of the debate about godsknowledge of the future since it dealswith specifics on what and how god knows the future. The recent evangelical debate about divine divine foreknowledge. If we are to come to a biblical understanding of the subject, we need to apply dilligence as we allow for the holy spirit to lead us into his truth. The result is a unique opportunity for readers to grapple with the issues and arguments and frame their own understanding of this important aspect of gods nature.
Scientific foreknowledge in the bible bible charts. Four views spectrum multiview book series kindle edition by james k. What these views are is covered in the description of the book, so i wont go into that here. Suppose that, prior to creating the universe, god believedthat you will drink a cup of coffee on. But the prophets were human beings and their foreknowledge of particular events, as stated in the midrashic passages, was a purely human foreknowledge, existing in a human, not a divine, mind.
Predestination, divine foreknowledge, and free will 1. And if he does know everything, do people truly have free will. James k beilby and paul r eddy, divine foreknowledge. Free will and foreknowledge university of notre dame. The ancient problem of fatalism, more particularly theological fatalism, has resurfaced with surprising vigour in the second half of the twentieth century. August 28, 2003 a deeply personal theological dilemma of mine is one that i probably have in common with a majority of christians. Foreknowledge and fatalism university of notre dame.
You know it completely vrije universiteit amsterdam. The author summarizes each views understanding of divine foreknowledge and then explains how this understanding applies to the views refutation of the problem of evil. They hold to meticulous providencecompatibilist freedom. Christian evidences scientific foreknowledge of the bible 2 3. The divine foreknowledge is simply gods knowledge of his own eternal purpose. This paper examines the issues of divine foreknowledge and the problem of evil from the standpoint of four different theological systems. Fatalist views of various sorts are views to the e ect that, in some sense or other, no one has a. Four views provides a unique venue for wellknown proponents of four distinct views to present their case. A compatible solution, on divine foreknowledge and human. Pdf following an open conception of divine foreknowledge, that holds that. Indeed, for many people, religion is the context in which questions about free will.
His books include john hicks pluralist philosophy of world religions ashgate, across the spectrum. Christs true family conforming image being chosen god, all knowing foreordained plans gods foreknowledge ethics, and grace christ, character of heart, divine reflecting gods heart goals spiritual adoption participation, in christ election, results in new birth, results of holiness of the saints christ our brother adoption, descriptions of. Rhoda introduction t he problem of divine foreknowledge and creaturely freedom or, more generally, the problem of divine knowledge of future contingents, has long been a matter of. Incompatibilists accept the incompatibility of infallible foreknowledge and human free will and deny either infallible foreknowledge or free will in the sense targeted by the argument.
Foreknowledge definition and meaning bible dictionary. This dilemma has to do with the apparent incompatibility of divine foreknowledge and libertarian. On divine foreknowledge and human freedom while walking down a wilderness trail, being x came to a place where the road diverged in two directionsone to. This is a comparison of four views of gods foreknowledge from different scholars. Augustine on divine foreknowledge and human free will. The question of the nature of gods foreknowledge and how that. The kabod volume 2 issue 2spring 2016 article 4 january 2016 divine foreknowledge and the problem of evil. There are four major views on divine foreknowledge that attempt to explain the extent to which gods knowledge of the future reaches. Divine foreknowledge provides a basis for comparison for four views on the subject. Omniscience the ancient problem of fatalism, more particularly theological fatalism, has resurfaced with surprising vigor in the second half of the twentieth century. Open theism, simple foreknowledge, molinism, and calvinism.
Foreknowledge and free will stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Spectrum multiview book series divine foreknowledge. Theological fatalism is the thesis that infallible foreknowledge of a human act makes. To gods elect, exiles scattered throughout the provinces of pontus, galatia, cappadocia, asia and bithynia, who have been chosen according to the foreknowledge of god the father, through the sanctifying work of the spirit, to be obedient to jesus christ and sprinkled with his blood.
I will just make a few points on the strengths and weaknesses of the book. The problem of freedom and foreknowledge was and remains central to the philosophy of religion, beginning in the 6th century with boethius 1962, who argued that god was outside of time and therefore it is false that gods knowledge of how i will act precedes my acting. Divine foreknowledge and human free will friends of. Omniscience is the transliteration of a compound latin word omnis, meaning all and scire, to know, thus allknowing. Divine foreknowledge and the biblical support for open theism. See cottrell, the classical arminian view of election, in perspectives on election. The problem of divine foreknowledge and future contigents from aristotle to suarez. It is extremely difficult to understand how this human foreknowledge can be compatible with human free will. Compatibilists must either identify a false premise in the argument for theological fatalism or show that the conclusion does not follow from the premises. By combining his middle knowledge with what he decides to create, god. Rowe, in his article augustine on foreknowledge and free.
I also attempt to show that the range of knowledge available to god in theological models that deny divine foreknowledge is significantly less than claimed by proponents of these views. Gods foreknowledge, like his logically prior middle knowledge. There are four premises that are not straightforward substitutions in. In this essay, i argue that divine foreknowledge is valuable to christian theism and that a hefty theological price must be paid if it is rejected. Free will and foreknowledge bibliography philpapers. Religious belief and free will debates about free will are impacted by religion as well as by science, as noted in chapter 1. Foreknowledge and fatalism phil 195 je speaks march 11, 2008. Although, church history bears witness to a diversity of opinions regarding the nature and content of gods divine foreknowledge, the need for careful and scholarly examination remains as relevant and important as any point in church history. Divine foreknowledge and the biblical support for open. This noun is found only twice in the bible and is used in the context of divine foreknowledge. Foreknowledge for those god foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the likeness of his son, that he might be the firstborn among many brothers v. Four views both with paul eddy, naturalism defeated.
If you are interested in purchasing this, you can do so on. While mans knowledge of science has been rather limited until recent years, the bibles handling of scientific facts is accurate despite mans ignorance. Four views condition new four different viewpoints that answer the question of the nature of gods foreknowledge and how that relates to human freedom. Pdf all is foreseen, and freedom of choice is granted. As a volume in the spectrum multiview books series, the book features four theologians, each defending a different view of gods omniscience. For a more sophisticated, philosophical defense of the fact that divine foreknowledge does not negate libertarian freedom, see david hunt, the simpleforeknowledge view, divine foreknowledge. On divine foreknowledge and human freedom while walking down a wilderness trail, being x came to a place where the road diverged in two directionsone to the left, and one to the right.
Omniscience is an attribute having to do with knowledge. Ockham 1983 distinguished between hard and soft facts, where hard facts alone are entirely about the past. There are two main views held by christians today regarding foreknowledge. The compatibility of divine foreknowledge and human freedom. Just to recap, this past spring i read a book called divine foreknowledge. Theological fatalism incompatibility of divine foreknowledge and libertarian freedom. Eddy the above is a book i read about a year or two ago.
When applied to god, it means by definition, without limit. Assumptions and misunderstandings abound concerning the doctrine of gods foreknowledge. Open theisms main objection to divine foreknowledge, voiced by calvinists and these noncalvinists alike, is that such foreknowledge of mans future acts is incompatible with free will. Boethius on divine foreknowledge and human free will. I also attempt to show that the range of knowledge available to god in theological models that deny divine foreknowledge is significantly less than claimed by proponents of.
Boyd, god limits his control, in four views on divine providence, eds. Calvinisimjohn calvin15091564 augustine had views before b. A compatible solution, on divine foreknowledge and human freedom. Many philosophers consider omniscience to be an attribute possessed only by a divine being, such as the god of western monotheism. Sep, 2006 divine foreknowledge four views with contributions by gregorary a. The foreknowledge of god is one of those facets of his attributes that has ever intrigued men in their limited capacities. Understanding issues in evangelical theology with g. The recent evangelical debate about divine foreknowledge has been compared to the inerrancy debate of the 1970s because of its heatedness. Where it comments on those facts, we can expect it to be correct because of gods infinite understanding.
812 671 860 637 632 1170 751 325 1335 975 1214 840 1600 508 639 804 77 1074 488 1036 729 392 528 1467 857 353 247 138 1458 1493 775